Article by Kenneth Z. Chutchian reprinted with permission of the Boston Globe
It was a spiritual journey as well as the pursuit of a second career that led high school teacher Gerald Hoff to New Zealand to study the carvings and history of the Maori people. He wanted to become a sculptor, and, as his wife Valerie said, “Carving is as basic to this culture as the weaving of plaid woolens would be to Scotland.”
How lucky could they be? Back home in Maine, the state animal, the moose, had a bone texture that was almost perfect for carving into stone. As he made the transition from teacher to artist, Gerald Hoff thought he was very fortunate indeed.
Of course, Hoff was on the verge of becoming a criminal, but he didn’t know that when he tried selling his jewelry last year. The Hoffs were gaining momentum with their new lives as artisan-carvers when they realized, quite by accident, that their newly created moose-bone jewelry could not be sold legally. For reasons that even state wildlife experts struggle to explain, Maine has banned the sale of moose bone since 1981, when the state began regulating moose hunts.
Want to sell antlers? Fine. Hoofs? That’s OK, too. Moose heads or hides? Perfectly legal. Ditto for every conceivable body part, including bones of deer, coyote, and bear carcasses. But offer a moose bone for legal tender in Maine and you are conducting an illegal transaction.
“I suspect it was because no one ever thought it would be sold,” said state Representative Elaine Fuller of Manchester, who is sponsoring a bill to lift the ban on moose-bone sales. The bill has been unanimously endorsed by the Legislature’s inland fisheries and wildlife committee and is awaiting votes by the House and Senate.
All it takes to make the Hoffs legitimate merchants is the insertion of the word “bones” into Section 1, Maine Revised Statutes 7464, subsection 9 (a): “Notwithstanding subsection 8, the head, antlers, feet and hide of any moose may be sold.”
As simple as that task may sound, the Hoffs’ predicament had state wildlife officials scratching their heads over why moose bones were singled out as contraband. At one time, there may have been legitimate concerns about unregulated sales of big game body parts leading to poaching, said Andrea Erskine, administrative assistant with the state Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife.
Another possible explanation, Erskine said, is that nobody had the foresight to imagine a market for moose bone. Heads and antlers are good for mounting. The meat is good for eating. The feet are cool to look at and put on display. But moose bone?
The Hoffs say moose bone cuts easier and is more appealing to the discerning eye than the bones of deer, bear, bulls, or cows. It has more grain than beef bone. “It is definitely a denser bone, and because the shape of the bone is more of a triangle, it is much easier to get a wide, flat surface,” said Valerie Hoff. “This makes it easier to do the initial drawings on the bone.”
The timing of the moose-bone bill may be fortuitous for the Inland Fisheries and Wildlife department. Although there is no intended connection between Fuller’s bill and efforts to increase the annual moose hunt in Maine, department officials were happy to endorse a measure that may encourage moose kills.
Maine is having trouble controlling the population of moose. The state now has 30,000 moose; the Legislature is debating separate bills that would increase the number of moose-hunting permits from 2,000 to 3,000 annually. The intent is to ultimately save Maine’s beloved state animal; too many moose means the animals compete for a limited food supply.
Let it never be said that Maine treates its moose like any other animal. Maine moose, after all, live under a different set of rules. While the Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife has authority to change state rules on the hunting of deer, bear, coyote, or turkey, the agency must turn to the Legislature to amend rules and laws affecting moose.
The Hoffs have known for some time that there’s money to be made by marketing moose. Tourists drive all over Maine’s unorganized townships to photograph moose. They purchase petrified moose droppings at museums, trading posts, and country stores. Credit unions offer “moose dollars” for elementary school children to exchange for small toys when they open their first savings accounts.
“Moose are so much a part of Maine, and, being ungainly, rather homely looking things, they are often treated with humorous disrespect,” Valerie Hoff said. “But, believe me, when people wear a moose-bone carving, it is generally with a sense of pride.”
The Hoffs stumbled into their new line of work. Gerald had been a sculptor and a high school arts teacher for 25 years before the moose-bone opportunity presented itself. A friend in Mount Vernon, Jeff Stevens, stopped by the Hoffs’ house one day in the summer of 1997 and reported that his mother-in-law had hit a moose with her car, killing the animal and totaling the vehicle. Stevens offered the moose bones to the Hoffs in exchange for a carving for his mother- in-law as a memento of her encounter.
That kind of fascination with moose intrigued the customers of Jed Davis, an Augusta jeweler who unwittingly tried to sell moose-bone carvings in his store. Davis is pleased to hear he won’t be breaking the law if he puts the Hoffs’ art on display once again.
“I haven’t bought any of that for a year,” said Davis. “But I always thought it was kind of cool.”